Sonin envelopes

For a solution of $w''+Q\,w=0$, Sonin's function $w^2+(w')^2/Q$ is monotone wherever $Q$ is monotone, a classical tool for the zeros and extrema of orthogonal polynomials. For polynomial solutions of a second-order equation, weighted versions of this function and of $w\,w'$ satisfy exact derivative identities, and these exclude roots from half-lines and intervals on which the normal-form coefficient is nonpositive.

Results

Let $a,b,c$ be polynomials and consider $$a\,y''+b\,y'+c\,y=0.$$ Put $$\Delta=4ac-2ab'+2a'b-b^2,\qquad W=2a\,y'+b\,y.$$ Away from the zeros of $a$, the substitution $y=e^{-\frac12\int b/a}\,w$ gives the normal form $w''+Q\,w=0$ with $Q=\Delta/(4a^2)$, and $W/(2a)$ equals $w'$ up to the same exponential factor. The Sonin envelope is the polynomial $$F=\Delta\,y^2+W^2,$$ so that $F/\Delta$ is, up to a positive factor, the Sonin function $w^2+(w')^2/Q$.

Theorem (root exclusion). Let $y\ne0$ be a polynomial solution of $a\,y''+b\,y'+c\,y=0$, and let $g,h,j$ be polynomials with $gh=aj$ and $a\,(g'h-gh')=(b-a')\,gh$. Suppose $a$ and $h$ do not vanish, $j>0$ and $\Delta\le0$ on $(-\infty,L]$, and $g\,y\,W/h\to0$ at $-\infty$. Then $y$ has no root in $(-\infty,L]$. The same hypotheses on $[L,\infty)$ with $g\,y\,W/h\to0$ at $+\infty$ give no root in $[L,\infty)$. On a finite interval $[L,U]$ with the same sign hypotheses, $y$ has no root in $(L,U]$ if $g\,y\,W/h\ge0$ at $L$, and no root in $[L,U]$ if $g\,y\,W/h>0$ at $L$.

Identities. Let $g,h$ be polynomials, let $R=a\,y''+b\,y'+c\,y$, $P=2a'\Delta-a\Delta'$ and $T=a\,(g'h-gh')-b\,gh$. Then, over any commutative ring, $$a\bigl((gF)'h\Delta-gF\,(h\Delta)'\bigr)-gh\,W^2P=\Delta F\,T+4agh\Delta W R.$$ For $K=yW$ and $\tilde T=a\,(g'h-gh')-(b-a')\,gh$, $$2a\bigl((gK)'h-gKh'\bigr)-gh\,(W^2-\Delta y^2)=2K\,\tilde T+4aghyR.$$

Theorem (derivatives). Let $a\ne0$, $gh=aj$ and $R=0$, and let $x$ be real. If $T=0$ and $(h\Delta)(x)\ne0$, then $gF/(h\Delta)$ has derivative $$\frac{j\,W^2P}{(h\Delta)^2}$$ at $x$. If $\tilde T=0$ and $h(x)\ne0$, then $gK/h$ has derivative $$\frac{j\,(W^2-\Delta y^2)}{2h^2}$$ at $x$.

Proof

On the region considered, $E=g\,y\,W/h$ is nondecreasing, since its derivative $j(W^2-\Delta y^2)/(2h^2)$ is nonnegative when $\Delta\le0$. At a root $r$ of $y$ we have $E(r)=0$ and $y'(r)\ne0$, hence $E'(r)=j(r)W(r)^2/(2h(r)^2)>0$ and $E$ is negative immediately to the left of $r$. This contradicts $E\ge0$ on the left, which follows from monotonicity and the limit at $-\infty$, or from the sign at $L$.

References

Definitions

  • Residual of the second-order operator

    Polynomial.Sonin.residualsource
    noncomputable def residual (a b c y : R[X]) : R[X] :=
      a * y.derivative.derivative + b * y.derivative + c * y
  • Discriminant of the normal form

    Polynomial.Sonin.discsource
    noncomputable def disc (a b c : R[X]) : R[X] :=
      4 * a * c - 2 * a * b.derivative + 2 * a.derivative * b - b ^ 2
  • First-order form 2ay' + by

    Polynomial.Sonin.linsource
    noncomputable def lin (a b y : R[X]) : R[X] :=
      2 * a * y.derivative + b * y
  • Sonin envelope

    Polynomial.Sonin.envelopesource
    noncomputable def envelope (a b c y : R[X]) : R[X] :=
      disc a b c * y ^ 2 + lin a b y ^ 2
  • Cross product y W

    Polynomial.Sonin.crosssource
    noncomputable def cross (a b y : R[X]) : R[X] :=
      y * lin a b y
  • Weight defect of a rational weight

    Polynomial.Sonin.weightDefectsource
    noncomputable def weightDefect (a b g h : R[X]) : R[X] :=
      a * (g.derivative * h - g * h.derivative) - b * g * h

Theorems

  • Sonin identity for the envelope

    Polynomial.Sonin.envelope_identitysource
    theorem envelope_identity :
        a * ((g * envelope a b c y).derivative * h * disc a b c -
            g * envelope a b c y * (h * disc a b c).derivative) -
          g * h * lin a b y ^ 2 * signPoly a b c =
        disc a b c * envelope a b c y * weightDefect a b g h +
          4 * a * g * h * disc a b c * lin a b y * residual a b c y
  • Sonin identity for the cross product

    Polynomial.Sonin.cross_identitysource
    theorem cross_identity :
        2 * a * ((g * cross a b y).derivative * h - g * cross a b y * h.derivative) -
          g * h * (lin a b y ^ 2 - disc a b c * y ^ 2) =
        2 * cross a b y * weightDefect a (b - a.derivative) g h +
          4 * a * g * h * y * residual a b c y
  • Derivative of the weighted envelope quotient

    Polynomial.Sonin.hasDerivAt_envelope_divsource
    theorem hasDerivAt_envelope_div (ha : a ≠ 0) (hgh : g * h = a * j)
        (hR : residual a b c y = 0) (hT : weightDefect a b g h = 0)
        (hx : (h * disc a b c).eval x ≠ 0) :
        HasDerivAt (fun t => (g * envelope a b c y).eval t / (h * disc a b c).eval t)
          ((j * lin a b y ^ 2 * signPoly a b c).eval x / ((h * disc a b c).eval x) ^ 2) x
  • Derivative of the weighted cross-product quotient

    Polynomial.Sonin.hasDerivAt_cross_divsource
    theorem hasDerivAt_cross_div (ha : a ≠ 0) (hgh : g * h = a * j)
        (hR : residual a b c y = 0) (hT : weightDefect a (b - a.derivative) g h = 0)
        (hx : h.eval x ≠ 0) :
        HasDerivAt (fun t => (g * cross a b y).eval t / h.eval t)
          ((j * (lin a b y ^ 2 - disc a b c * y ^ 2)).eval x / (2 * h.eval x ^ 2)) x
  • No roots on a left half-line

    Polynomial.Sonin.eval_ne_zero_of_tendsto_atBotsource
    theorem eval_ne_zero_of_tendsto_atBot (hy : y ≠ 0) (hgh : g * h = a * j)
        (hR : residual a b c y = 0) (hT : weightDefect a (b - a.derivative) g h = 0) {L : ℝ}
        (ha : ∀ x ≤ L, a.eval x ≠ 0) (hh : ∀ x ≤ L, h.eval x ≠ 0) (hj : ∀ x ≤ L, 0 < j.eval x)
        (hΔ : ∀ x ≤ L, (disc a b c).eval x ≤ 0)
        (hlim : Tendsto (fun t => (g * cross a b y).eval t / h.eval t) atBot (𝓝 0)) :
        ∀ x ≤ L, y.eval x ≠ 0
  • No roots on a finite interval from a sign condition at the left endMain result

    Polynomial.Sonin.eval_ne_zero_of_mem_Iocsource
    theorem eval_ne_zero_of_mem_Ioc (hy : y ≠ 0) (hgh : g * h = a * j)
        (hR : residual a b c y = 0) (hT : weightDefect a (b - a.derivative) g h = 0) {L U : ℝ}
        (ha : ∀ x ∈ Icc L U, a.eval x ≠ 0) (hh : ∀ x ∈ Icc L U, h.eval x ≠ 0)
        (hj : ∀ x ∈ Icc L U, 0 < j.eval x) (hΔ : ∀ x ∈ Icc L U, (disc a b c).eval x ≤ 0)
        (hL : 0 ≤ (g * cross a b y).eval L / h.eval L) :
        ∀ x ∈ Ioc L U, y.eval x ≠ 0

Lean source RealRooted/Challenges/Roots/SoninEnvelope.lean at revision d6670742. Formalized 2026-11-03.