Laguerre's theorem on polar derivatives

The polar derivative of a degree-$n$ polynomial with respect to a pole outside a closed disk or half-plane containing all its zeros has degree $n-1$ and all its zeros in the same set.

Results

For $A\in\mathbb C[z]$, $n\ge1$ and $\zeta\in\mathbb C$, the polar derivative of order $n$ with pole $\zeta$ is $$ D_\zeta A(z)=n\,A(z)+(\zeta-z)\,A'(z). $$ For $n=\deg A$ it has degree at most $n-1$. For a real polynomial $f$ and $a\in\mathbb R$ we write $D_af=n f+(a-z)f'$ with $n=\deg f$.

Theorem (Laguerre, closed disk). Let $\deg A=n\ge1$ and let $D=\{z:|z-c|\le r\}$ with $r\ge0$. If all zeros of $A$ lie in $D$ and $\zeta\notin D$, then all zeros of $D_\zeta A$ lie in $D$, and $\deg D_\zeta A=n-1$.

Theorem (Laguerre, closed half-plane). Let $\deg A=n\ge1$, let $b\in\mathbb R$ and $H=\{z:\operatorname{Im}z\le b\}$. If all zeros of $A$ lie in $H$ and $\zeta\notin H$, then all zeros of $D_\zeta A$ lie in $H$, and $\deg D_\zeta A=n-1$.

Theorem (Laguerre, real line). If $f\in\mathbb R[z]$ is zero or real-rooted, then so is $D_af$ for every real $a$.

Use

These statements drive Grace's apolarity theorem: the polar derivative with a pole outside the disk or half-plane keeps all zeros in the region while lowering the degree by one.

Proof

For the disk and the half-plane, let $w$ outside the region be a zero of $D_\zeta A$. Then $n/(w-\zeta)=\sum_j1/(w-z_j)$ over the zeros $z_j$ of $A$. The map $z\mapsto1/(w-z)$ sends the region to a convex set, which then contains the average of the $1/(w-z_j)$, forcing $\zeta$ into the region. For the real line, translating $a$ to $0$ turns $D_af$ into $ng-zg'$, which is the reflection of the derivative of the reflection of $g$; reflection preserves real-rootedness, and the derivative of a real-rooted polynomial is real-rooted by Rolle's theorem.

References

See [RS02].

  1. [RS02] Q. I. Rahman & G. Schmeisser. Analytic Theory of Polynomials. London Mathematical Society Monographs, Oxford University Press, 2002.
    BibTeX
    @book{RahmanSchmeisser2002,
      author    = {Rahman, Q. I. and Schmeisser, G.},
      title     = {Analytic Theory of Polynomials},
      publisher = {Oxford University Press},
      series    = {London Mathematical Society Monographs},
      year      = {2002}
    }

Definitions

  • Polar derivative nA + (ζ − z)A′ of a degree-n polynomial

    RealRooted.polarDerivsource
    def polarDeriv (n : Nat) (ζ : ℂ) (A : ℂ[X]) : ℂ[X] :=
      C (n : ℂ) * A + (C ζ - X) * derivative A
  • Polar derivative of a polynomial with respect to a point

    RealRooted.polarDerivativesource
    noncomputable def polarDerivative (a : R) (f : R[X]) : R[X] :=
      C (f.natDegree : R) * f + (C a - X) * derivative f
  • All roots lie in a set

    Polynomial.RootsInsource
    def RootsIn {R : Type*} [Semiring R] (s : Set R) (p : R[X]) : Prop :=
      ∀ z : R, p.IsRoot z → z ∈ s
  • Closed lower half-plane

    RealRooted.lowerHalfsource
    def lowerHalf (b : ℝ) : Set ℂ := {z : ℂ | z.im ≤ b}

Theorems

  • Laguerre's theorem for a closed diskMain result

    RealRooted.polarDeriv_rootsInsource
    theorem polarDeriv_rootsIn {n : Nat} {c : ℂ} {r : ℝ} (hr : 0 ≤ r) {ζ : ℂ}
        {A : ℂ[X]} (hn : 1 ≤ n) (hA : A.natDegree = n)
        (hAroots : A.RootsIn (Metric.closedBall c r))
        (hζ : ζ ∉ Metric.closedBall c r) :
        (polarDeriv n ζ A).RootsIn (Metric.closedBall c r)
  • Laguerre's theorem for a closed half-plane

    RealRooted.polarDeriv_rootsIn_lowerHalfsource
    theorem polarDeriv_rootsIn_lowerHalf {n : Nat} {b : ℝ} {ζ : ℂ}
        {A : ℂ[X]} (hn : 1 ≤ n) (hA : A.natDegree = n)
        (hAroots : A.RootsIn (lowerHalf b))
        (hζ : ζ ∉ lowerHalf b) :
        (polarDeriv n ζ A).RootsIn (lowerHalf b)
  • The polar derivative drops the degree by exactly one (closed disk)

    RealRooted.polarDeriv_natDegreesource
    theorem polarDeriv_natDegree {n : Nat} {c : ℂ} {r : ℝ} {ζ : ℂ}
        {A : ℂ[X]} (hn : 1 ≤ n) (hA : A.natDegree = n)
        (hAroots : A.RootsIn (Metric.closedBall c r))
        (hζ : ζ ∉ Metric.closedBall c r) :
        (polarDeriv n ζ A).natDegree = n - 1
  • The polar derivative drops the degree by exactly one (closed half-plane)

    RealRooted.polarDeriv_natDegree_lowerHalfsource
    theorem polarDeriv_natDegree_lowerHalf {n : Nat} {b : ℝ} {ζ : ℂ}
        {A : ℂ[X]} (hn : 1 ≤ n) (hA : A.natDegree = n)
        (hAroots : A.RootsIn (lowerHalf b))
        (hζ : ζ ∉ lowerHalf b) :
        (polarDeriv n ζ A).natDegree = n - 1

Lean source RealRooted/Challenges/Roots/LaguerrePolarDerivative.lean at revision d6670742. Formalized 2026-07-01.